Skip to main content
Home About Search Developments Resources Blog Contact {{agentDetails.offc_phone}}

{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home in America sold at a premium compared to the previous year, but that trend has come to a halt. Recent data for October indicates the median sales price has dipped slightly below its level from a year prior, marking the first annual drop since spring 2023. Concurrently, the inventory of homes on the market has reached its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have declined to their lowest level in over a decade, outside of the initial pandemic phase, and around 20% of listings have seen price reductions.

However, borrowing costs have risen again. Over the past week, the average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has climbed back into the mid-7% range following a brief period of decline. This means that while buyers now hold more negotiating power, monthly payments remain a significant challenge for many households.

This unique situation presents distinct opportunities. Sellers are receiving fewer offers and are seeing homes linger longer on the market, leading to greater flexibility regarding listing prices and sale terms. If you're in the market for a home this winter, here's what you might be able to negotiate, including key factors to discuss with your real estate agent and lender.

Understanding the Implications of a Price Decline

A national dip of less than half a percent is far from a market crash and doesn't imply that prices are decreasing everywhere. Certain expensive coastal markets with limited inventory are still enjoying substantial gains, whereas several substantial metropolitan areas in the South and West have experienced declines of several percentage points compared to a year ago. Your local market dynamics play a far more crucial role than the national average.

This shift in the national market indicates that the balance of negotiating power has changed. With homes taking longer to sell and many listings competing for a shrinking buyer pool, sellers become increasingly open to discussions. This openness can often translate into adjustments not just in price but also in sale terms.

Beyond Just the Price

While many buyers fixate solely on the listing price, in a high-interest-rate environment, the monthly payment and upfront cash needed at closing can be even more significant. A reduction of a few thousand dollars in price only slightly impacts your loan. The same amount of money can sometimes be better utilized in other areas that could benefit your budget more effectively. Key points for buyers to negotiate in a slower market may include:

  • A lower price than the current listing
  • A seller credit to assist with closing costs
  • Completion of repairs prior to closing, or a price adjustment in lieu of repairs
  • Funds from the seller to reduce your mortgage rate
  • A flexible closing schedule or timeline that fits your needs
  • Inclusions like appliances or window coverings as part of the sale

Your real estate agent can provide insight on how local sellers are responding and help you determine which of these priorities to emphasize in your offer. Your aim should not be to request everything available but to focus on aspects that will have the most substantial impact on your situation.

Relief from Closing Costs

The costs associated with closing can typically account for a few percent of the overall loan amount, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, securing this cash can be the toughest hurdle. A seller credit can alleviate some of these expenses, allowing you to bring less cash to closing.

However, there are limits to what can be offered. Various loan programs set caps on seller contributions, usually between 3% and 9% of the price, contingent on the type of loan and your down payment size, and the credit typically cannot exceed your actual closing costs. It's advisable to consult your lender early on to understand your specific loan terms to ensure any requests in your offer adhere to these guidelines.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates exceeding 7%, one of the most beneficial options a seller can provide might involve assistance with your interest rate. Two primary methods exist for this.

A permanent buydown entails paying discount points at closing to reduce your mortgage rate for the entirety of the loan. Each point costs 1% of the loan amount, and the rate reduction will vary based on lender and market conditions. If you plan to hold onto the loan for an extended period, a permanent buydown could prove rewarding.

A temporary buydown, in contrast, lowers your payment for the initial year or two. A common approach is to reduce the rate by two percentage points in the first year and by one in the second, returning to the standard rate afterward. For instance, with a $350,000 loan at an approximate rate of 7.34%, your principal and interest payment would roughly be $2,409 a month. With a temporary buydown, your first-year payment might drop to about $1,952, followed by a second-year payment of around $2,176, reverting to the original rate in year three. The cost for this arrangement would be approximately $8,000, which a seller could cover instead of offering a similar price reduction.

Keep in mind, a temporary buydown isn't a permanent solution. You must still be comfortable with the full payment after the discount period ends, as lenders typically assess you based on that higher rate. While refinancing could be an option should rates decrease later on, there are no guarantees when or if that will occur.

Don't Forego Inspections Out of Fear

In a competitive market, many buyers previously opted to waive inspections or limit their requests to enhance their bids. However, with the easing of market pressure, there is less necessity for relinquishing such protections. Conducting a detailed home inspection enables you to gain insights into the condition of the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical setups, and foundation before committing.

If the inspection identifies issues, your agent can assist in deciding whether to request repairs, adjust the purchase price, or ask for a credit. Opting for a credit can often be simpler than managing seller-conducted repairs, as it grants you control over who completes the work and its execution, though the ideal choice will depend on the specific problem and your loan stipulations.

Get Your Financing in Order First

Your negotiating power means very little if your financing is unreliable. When a seller is comparing two offers, they typically prefer the buyer who appears more likely to complete the sale. Prior to commencing serious house hunting, aim for a full preapproval instead of a simple prequalification. Understand your ideal monthly payment, rather than only focusing on the maximum loan amount, and obtain estimates from multiple lenders. Make sure to inquire with each lender regarding their policies on seller credits or buydowns to avoid any unexpected developments.

Key Questions to Present to Your Agent

  • How long are properties in this area typically on the market, and what is the frequency of price reductions?
  • Would a price decrease, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown provide the most budgetary relief?
  • How does this specific home's condition and history influence my negotiation strategy?
  • What contingencies should I include in my offer for adequate protection?

The Final Takeaway

A less competitive market does not equate to lower prices, especially with mortgage rates rising once more. However, it presents prepared buyers with the opportunity to negotiate terms that better suit their financial situation. With appropriate financing, clarity on your priorities, and support from your agent and lender, you might secure favorable terms that were previously unattainable.

Rewritten using AI